Posts

Employees Obtain Significant Victory In U.S. Department of Labor Administrative Review Board Ruling

The U.S. Department of Labor’s Administrative Review Board (ARB) issued a 3-2 decision in favor of a whistleblower, Robert Powers, in  Powers v. Union Pacific Railroad Company,  ARB Case No. 13-034,  in a decision that was a resounding victory for employees asserting whistleblower claims.  In Powers  the ARB held that the correct standard of proof was a contributing factor causation standard for retaliation claims brought under various whistleblower laws enforced by the U.S. Department of Labor.  Prior to the decision in Powers,  a whistleblower was required to show that his protected activity was the “but for” cause of his termination or other adverse employment action. After  Powers  an employee need only prove that the protected activity was a “contributing factor” leading to an adverse employment action.  This distinction is significant for many reasons, including, perhaps most importantly, an employee's ability to get to...

US Supreme Court Issues Important Decision Affirming Accommodation Rights for Pregnant Employees

In a decision written by Justice Breyer the United States Supreme Court in Young v. United Parcel Service, Inc. reaffirmed protections for pregnant workers under the Pregnancy Discrimination Act.  In its decision, the Court held that a pregnant worker may show disparate treatment by showing that she sought an accommodation, that the employer failed to accommodate her, but that the employer accommodated other non-pregnant employees who were "similar in their ability or inability to work." The Court further held that an employee can create a triable jury issue by providing evidence that the employer's policies prohibiting accommodation for pregnant workers impose a significant burden, and that the employer's reason for the policy are not sufficiently strong to justify the burden, but instead give rise to an inference of intentional discrimination. Peggy Young, the appellant, worked for UPS as a delivery driver.  She requested a leave of absence in order to undergo...

Proving or Defending Against Age Discrimination Claims in the Workplace

Employees and employers are often confronted with claims of age discrimination in the workplace. Most studies indicate that age discrimination is a real presence in today's workforce. This form of employment discrimination is illegal under a number of different circumstances and in different settings. Unfortunately, age discrimination can be uniquely difficult to prove. Thankfully, there are a number of ways in which you can aid your attorney in helping to back up your claim with solid evidence. If you hope to prove that you are being discriminated against because of your age at work, it is imperative that you let your attorney know if any of the following scenarios have occurred in regards to your situation. 1) statements made to you or directed at you that include age-based comments, or that can be inferred as being age-based; 2) evidence that you were treated differently than those younger than you with respect to the terms, conditions and privileges of employment; 3) evidence t...

Utah Legislature Passes Landmark Anti-discrimination Bill Providing Protections For Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity

On March 12, 2015 the Utah Legislature passed a landmark discrimination bill extending protections in Utah's Antidiscrimination Act of 1965 to sexual orientation and gender identity.  The bill has been recognized across the United States as a progressive step toward balancing the competing interests of the LGBT community with religious expression.   The bill  amends the Utah Antidiscrimination Act of 1965 and Utah's Fair Housing Act to provide protections to the LGBT community.  While the bill sidestepped the issue of whether private business owners, based on truly held religious beliefs, may refuse services to to homosexuals, it provides clear protections for employees against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. The bill modified Utah Code Ann. Section 34A-5-106 to prohibit discrimination in the terms, privileges and conditions of employment, or the hiring, promotion, demotion or termination of an employee because of ...

Utah Supreme Court issues Important Decision Holding Employers May Owe Duty of Reasonable Care to Third-Party in Hiring, Traning & Supervising Employees

In a recent decision written but Justice Lee (with a very well-reasoned dissent by Justice Nehring), the Utah Supreme Court in Graves v. North Eastern Services, Inc ., 2015 UT 28, held that the “fault” to be apportioned under Utah Code Section 78B-5-818 (Utah's comparative negligence statute) is not limited to negligence but extends to intentional torts. Additionally, and perhaps more importantly for Utah employers, the Court held that employers may owe a duty of reasonable care to third-parties in hiring, training and supervising employees in certain circumstances. Lastly, the Court held that expert testimony on the standard of care was not needed with respect to questions of ordinary negligence. Where the standard implicates scientific matters beyond the capacity of an ordinary juror, however, expert testimony may be required, such as in medical malpractice cases. In Graves, the parents of a minor girl who had been assaulted at one of the Defendant's client'' re...

Utah Supreme Court Clarifies "Good Cause" to Quit Standard for Receipt of Unemployment Benefits in Utah

In an opinion issued today the Utah Supreme Court settled the appropriate standard of review for an appellate court's review of a denial of unemployment benefits, holding that in a case of a worker quitting for good cause, the determination is a fact-like mixed question, and appellate courts should apply a deferential standard of review to a lower tribunal’s resolution of this issue, but must be vigilant to ensure that they are based on correct legal principles.  Sawyer v. Dept. of Workforce Services , 2015 UT 33, ¶ 47. The Court further held, in a victory for employees, that the relevant inquiry in a good case quit case is whether a reasonably prudent person would be justified in quitting under the circumstances, and that quitting in order to avoid a discharge does not automatically bar an employee from receiving unemployment benefits. Id . at ¶ 30. In Sawyer , the Dept. of Workforce Services denied Sawyer’s application for unemployment benefits based upon its finding that ...

Utah Supreme Court Clarifies Scope of Utah Payment of Wages Act by Holding LLC Managers are not Personally Liable for Unpaid Wages

In a much anticipated decision for Utah employers and employees, the Utah Supreme Court in Heaps v. Nuriche 2015 UT 26, held that the Utah Payment of Wages Act (UPWA) does not include LLC managers as "employers" who are liable for the non-payment of wages under the UPWA. As noted earlier, this ruling is contrary to the Labor Commission's long-standing interpretation of the scope of the UPWA, and its practice of holding officers liable for wage claim violations. At issue in Heaps was whether the UPWA imposed personal liability on managers of a limited liability company for unpaid wages of employees.  The Plaintiffs, Ron Heaps and Phillip Sykes, along with other individuals, founded Nuriche, LLC, a limited liability company formed in Nevada which conducted business in Utah.  Heaps and Sykes brought suit alleging that the other founding members of Nuriche promised them compensation and other benefits in connection with their employment by Nuriche, but that Nuriche and th...

Utah Supreme Court Drops "Improper Purpose" as a Viable Method of Proving Intentional Interference with Prospective Economic Relations Claims

In a very important decision issued yesterday, the Utah Supreme Court in Eldridge v. Johndrow , 2015 UT 21, abandoned the "improper purpose" avenue of proving intentional interference with prospective economic relations claims.   Despite recognizing that proof of interference for an improper purpose has been the law since the Court's decision more than 30 years ago in Leigh Furniture & Carpet Co.v. Isom , 657 P.2d 293, 307 (Utah 1982), the Court side-stepped its prior precedent, referenced the risks inherent in proving motive or purpose and the potential for causing juries to find liability too easily for "legitimate commercial activity" to justify its reversal.  The Court further noted that despite its attempt to circumscribe the doctrine by allowing improper-purpose liability only where “the improper purpose predominate[s]” and by counseling that it would usually be “prudent” not to apply the doctrine to “commercial conduct," such attempts had been ...

New Guidance on Pregnancy Discrimination and Bias

Amid controversy, and with a pending United States Supreme Court decision lurking in the background - the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued updated guidance on discrimination, harassment and bias under the Pregnancy Discrimination Act. A fact sheet created by the EEOC for small businesses addressing the new guidancecan be accessed here .  Under the PDA, employers are required to treat women affected by pregnancy, childbirth and related medical conditions in the same manner as other employees (or applicants for employment) with respect to leave time, attendance issues and other work-related restrictions. Employers cannot discriminate against employees because of their pregnancy, pregnancy related medical conditions, childbirth or past pregnancy, or because of an employer's intention, desire or potential to become pregnant. Such prohibition also includes discrimination on the basis of lactation or breastfeeding. The PDA also prohibits harassment because of ...

Sexual Harassment Claims in Male Dominated Industries

In an article last week by USA Today, reporter Jessica Guynn details allegations relating to the purported sexism that is rampant in Silicon Valley's technology industry and the technology profession in general. It's a good read for employees and employers who operate in industries typically dominated by male employees, such as construction, firefighting, law enforcement, accounting/finance and politics. Employers who operate businesses in such industries need to be extremely vigilant with implementing and enforcing sexual harassment policies and procedures. In addition, employers need to pay close attention to hiring, pay and promotion practices to avoid claims of gender discrimination in compensation, promotion and hiring decisions. Employees who work in such industries who suspect that they are being treated differently on the basis of gender should seek competent legal counsel who can assist employees with analyzing their situations and exploring possible legal remedi...

Tenth Circuit Affirms U.S. District of Utah Judge Robert J. Shelby's Decision Barring Utah's Ban on Same-Sex Marriage

Last week, in a divided decision issued by Judge Lucero, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, in Kitchen v. Herbert, Case. No. 13-4178 , affirmed Judge Shelby's (U.S. District Court of Utah) decision holding that the Due Process Clause and Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution protect those who wish to marry a person of the same sex in the same way they protect those who wish to marry a person of the opposite sex, and declared that Utah's Amendment 3 to its constitution banning same-sex marriage did not withstanding strict scrutiny because the right to marry is a fundamental right protected by the Constitution.   In a 108 page opinion with included a lengthy dissent from Judge Kelly, the Tenth Circuit concluded that the State of Utah may not deny a citizen benefit of the right to marry based solely on the sex of the person the citizen chooses to marry. For more information about the decision, and what Utah plans to do in response to the decision, yo...

U.S. Supreme Court Issues Unanimous Opinion Protecting Government Employee's Free Speech Rights

In a unanimous decision  issued by the United States Supreme Court and written by Justice Sotomayor, the U.S. Supreme Court re-emphasized the importance of protecting government employees free speech rights. The Court, in Lane v. Franks, reversed the Eleventh Circuit's decision upholding summary judgment against Mr. Lane and held that Lane's sworn testimony outside the scope of his ordinary job duties was entitled to First Amendment protection because it consisted of speech as a citizen of public concern and the government had no legitimate interest in treating Lane differently because of his speech, in accordance with the Court's decision in Pickering v. Board of Ed. of Township High School Dist.,  391 U. S. 563.  Under Pickering, if speech is made in fulfilling an employee’s ordinary job duties, then the employee is not speaking as a citizen for First Amendment purposes. But if the “employee spoke as a citizen on a matter of public concern,” the inquiry turns to whethe...

Pregnancy and Family Responsibility Discrimination under the ADA, FMLA and State and Local Laws

Today Forbes ran an article entitled " Proliferating State & Local Pregnancy Laws Make Modifying ADA/FMLA Procedures a Must for Most Employers "  which discusses the increasing trend among states and municipalities to enact pregnancy accommodation requirements with greater obligations for employers to accommodate employees who are pregnant than existing federal laws such as the Family & Medical Leave Act of 1993 and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, as amended by the ADAAA of 2008. While Utah has not enacted specific protections for pregnancy related accommodations beyond those found in the ADA, FMLA and Utah Antidiscrimination Act,  there is an increasing amount of litigation in Utah and across the United States involving pregnancy-related claims and caregiver discrimination (i.e., family responsibilities discrimination) and related claims. These cases include cases alleging discrimination, retaliation and/or harassment for being a caregiver to childr...